Showing posts with label Peter Rost. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Peter Rost. Show all posts

Sunday, August 19, 2007

What does the First Ever Pharma Blogosphere Survey tell us

First, let me make a few comments. I find John Mack's Pharma Marketing blog useful. Marketing tends to be a black box for me. From my perspective, for the inputs you have guys who want to sell things, and for the outputs you have commercials and other promotional materials. I (partly by choice and partly by the way my brain works) understand very little about what happens between input and output. All I know about it is play my strengths and downplay my weaknesses. This is part of the reason I'm limiting myself to discussing statistical issues, at least on this blog.

However, when he came out with his First Ever Pharma Blogosphere Survey®©™, I was skeptical. In fact, I didn't pay much attention to it. But then he started making claims based on the survey, especially surrounding Peter Rost's new gig at BrandweekNRX. His predicted Brandweek would "flush its creditibility down the toilet" by hiring Rost, and cited his survey data to back up his case (he had other arguments as well, but, as noted above, I'm just covering what I know). And since I'm skeptical of his data, I'm skeptical of his analysis, and, therefore, his arguments, conclusions, and predictions based on the data. To his credit, however, he posts the raw data so at least we know he didn't use a graphics program to draw his bar graphs.
Rost's counterarguments are worthy of analysis as well. He notes that most people read the Pharma Marketing blog (the survey was conducted from its sister site Pharma Blogosphere), raising the question about which population Mack was really sampling. The correct answer, of course, is people who happened to read that blog entry around the day it was posted who cared enough to bother to take a web survey. I would agree that Mack's following probably make up a bulk of the survey.
But more important is the comparison of the survey to more objective data, such as site counters. (Note that site counter data isn't perfect, either, but it is more objective than web polls since the data collection does not require user interaction.) And it looks like that objective data doesn't match Mack's data.
Then you throw in the data from eDrugSearch, which has its own algorithm for ranking healthcare websites, but they seem a very out of line with the ranking algorithm from that of Technorati, which uses some modifications to the number of incoming links (I think to adjust for the fact that some blogs just all link to one another).
So, at any rate, you can be sure that Peter Rost will keep you abreast of his rankings, and for now they certainly do not seem to match Mack's predictions. And, while the eDrugSearch and Technorati rankings seem far from perfect, they do tend to agree on the upward trend in readership of BrandweekNRx and Rost's personal blog, at least for now. Mack's survey, and the predictions based on them, are the only data I've seen so far that have not agreed.
In the meantime, I say the proof is in the pudding. Read these sites, or, better yet, put them in an RSS reader so you can skim for the material you like. Discard the material you don't like. As for me, well, I like to keep abreast of the news in my industry because, well, it could affect my ability to feed my children. So far, Rost's blog breaks news that doesn't get picked up anywhere else, (as does Pharmalot and PharmGossip). Mack's blogs did, too, at least until he started getting obsessed with his subjective evaluation of Rost's content.

Friday, July 20, 2007

Whistleblower on "statistical reporting system"

Whether you love or hate Peter Rost (and there seems to be very little in between), you can't work in the drug or CRO industry and ignore him. Yesterday, he and Ed Silverman (Pharmalot) broke a story on a director of statistics who blew the whistle on Novartis. Of course, this caught my eye.

While I can't really determine whether Novartis is "at fault" from these two stories (and related echos throughout the pharma blogs), I can tell you about statistical reporting systems, and why I think that these allegations can impact Novartis's bottom line in a major way.

Gone are the days of doing statistics with pencil, paper, and a desk calculator. These days, and especially in commercial work, statistics are all done with a computer. Furthermore, no statistical calculation is done in a vacuum. Especially in a clinical trial, there are thousands of these calculations which must be integrated and presented so that they can be interpreted by a team of scientists and doctors who then decide whether a drug is safe and effective (or, more accurately, whether a drug's benefits outweigh its risks).

A statistical reporting system, briefly, is a collection of standards, procedures, practices, and computer programs (usually SAS macros, but may involve programs in any language) that standardize the computation and reporting of statistics. Assuming they are well-written, these processes and programs are general enough to process the data any kind of study and produce reports that are consistent across all studies, and, hopefully, across all product lines in a company. For example, there may be one program to turn raw data into summary statistics (n, mean, median, standard deviation) and present them in a standardized way in a text table. Since this is a procedure we do many times, we'd like to just be able to "do it" without having to fuss over the details. We feed the variable name in (and perhaps some other details like number of decimal places) and voila the table. Not all statistics is that routine (and good for me because that means job security), but perhaps 70-80% is and can be made more efficient. Other programs and standards will take care of titles, footnotes, column headers, formatting, tracking, and validation in a standardized and efficient way. This saves a lot of time in both programming and in review and validation of tables.

So far, so good. But what happens when these systems break? As you might expect, you have to pay careful attention to these statistical reporting systems, even go so far as applying some software development life cycle methodology. If they break, you influence not just one calculation but perhaps thousands. And there is no way of knowing - obscure bugs in the code might influence just 10 out of a whole series of studies, where a more serious bug might affect everything. If this system is applied to every product in house (and it should probably be general enough to apply to at least one category of products, such as all cancer products), the integrity of the data analysis for a whole series of products is compromised.

Allegations were also made that a contract programmer was told to change dates on adverse events, which could either be a benign but bizarre request if the reasons for the change are well-documented (it's better to change dates in the database than at the program level, because it's easier to audit changes to a database and specific changes to specific dates keep a program from being generalizable to other similar circumstances) or an ethical nightmare if the changes were done to make the safety profile of the drug look better. From Pharmalot's report, the latter was alleged.

You might guess the consequences of systematic errors in data submitted to the FDA. The FDA does have the authority to kick out an application if it has good reason to believe that its data is incorrect. This application has to go through the resubmission process, after it is completely redone. (The FDA will only do this if there are systematic problems.) This erodes the confidence the reviewers have in the application, and probably even all applications submitted by a sponsor who made the errors. This kind of distrust is very costly, resulting in longer review periods, more work to assure the validity of the data, analysis, and interpretation, and, ultimately, lower profits. Much lower.

It doesn't look like the FDA has invoked its Application Integrity Policy on Novartis's Tasigna or any other product. But it has invoked its right to three more months of review time, saying it needs to "review additional data."

So, yes, this is big trouble as of now. Depending on the investigation, it could get bigger. A lot bigger.

Update: Pharmalot has posted a response from Novartis. In it, Novartis reiterates their confidence in the integrity of their data and claims to have proactively shared all data with the FDA (as they should). They also claim that the extension to the review time for the NDA was for the FDA to consider amendments to the submission.

This is a story to watch (and without judgment, for now, since this is currently a matter of "he said, she said"). And, BTW, I think Novartis responded very quickly. (Ed seems to think that 24 hours was too long.)